Why some companies hire controllers in 45 days while others spend months searching
The controller role has changed. So has the market for hiring one.
Today’s controllers are expected to do far more than oversee accounting operations and ensure accurate financial reporting.
Particularly in middle-market and private equity-backed businesses, controllers are increasingly responsible for improving financial visibility, implementing systems, supporting acquisitions and helping leadership teams make better business decisions.
As expectations have expanded, finding candidates with the right combination of technical expertise, industry experience and operational leadership has become increasingly challenging.
But here’s what we’ve learned from our controller searches at Aris Amplify: The companies that hire successfully aren’t necessarily the ones offering the highest compensation. They’re the ones that know what they need, understand the market and are prepared to make decisions.
We’ve seen companies secure exceptional controllers in 45 days or less, while others spend months searching for essentially the same profile. The difference often comes down to three things
1. Alignment on what the business actually needs
One of the most common challenges we encounter in controller searches isn’t a lack of qualified candidates but a lack of alignment among the people making the hiring decision.
A CEO may prioritize industry experience and someone who understands the day-to-day operations of the business. A CFO may place greater emphasis on technical accounting expertise, financial controls and reporting capabilities. A private equity sponsor may want someone with prior sponsor-backed experience who understands the pace, expectations and reporting requirements of institutional ownership.
All are reasonable priorities. The challenge comes when everyone expects to find those qualifications in one candidate without agreeing on which are truly essential.
Consider a founder-owned manufacturing company preparing for its first institutional investment. Its controller may need to establish stronger financial controls, improve reporting and build the infrastructure necessary to support growth.
Now consider a private equity-backed platform pursuing an aggressive acquisition strategy. That controller may need to manage multiple entities, integrate acquisitions, accelerate the monthly close and deliver timely financial information to investors and lenders.
Both positions require strong accounting leadership, but the experience needed to succeed in each environment can look very different.
Before beginning a search, leadership teams need to agree on what the controller must accomplish, not simply what qualifications should appear on a résumé. When that alignment happens early, the search becomes more focused, candidate evaluations become more productive and hiring decisions happen faster.
2. Compensation that reflects the role, not just the title
Controller compensation has become increasingly competitive, particularly for candidates with private equity experience, Big Four backgrounds and a demonstrated ability to lead through growth or organizational change.
In some of our searches, we’ve seen compensation expectations increase by more than 20% year-over-year for candidates with highly sought-after experience. This reflects the growing competition for specialized finance talent, as well as the expanding responsibilities companies are placing on these positions.
For hiring authorities, understanding these shifts early is critical to establishing realistic compensation parameters and avoiding unnecessary delays in the search process. But compensation benchmarking shouldn’t begin and end with a salary range.
A controller responsible for traditional accounting oversight is not necessarily comparable to one expected to lead ERP implementations, integrate acquisitions, manage multiple business units and serve as a strategic partner to the CFO.
Yet we frequently see companies seeking that broader level of experience while benchmarking compensation against a more traditional controller position.
The issue isn’t always that a company’s budget is too low. Sometimes the expectations of the position have outgrown the compensation assigned to it. This is particularly relevant in private equity-backed businesses, where controllers are increasingly expected to operate with the sophistication and commercial awareness historically associated with more senior finance leadership roles.
We’re also seeing more private equity-backed companies incorporate equity participation or other long-term incentives into compensation packages for key finance leaders. These incentives can be an important differentiator when attracting experienced controllers, particularly those who understand the demands of sponsor-backed environments and can contribute to the company’s long-term value creation plan.
The objective is to understand what the capabilities you’re seeking actually command in the market. Getting that right before launching a search can prevent weeks of interviewing candidates who were never realistically within reach.
The offer stage is where this preparation matters most. When an offer comes in below a candidate’s clearly communicated compensation expectations, the likelihood of acceptance drops dramatically. In our experience, roughly nine out of 10 candidates decline such offers.
Aligning on compensation before interviews begin—and revisiting expectations before extending an offer—helps avoid losing a strong candidate at the finish line. For a closer look at compensation trends, download our 2026 Aris Amplify Controller Compensation Report.
3. Understanding the tradeoffs that come with hiring requirements
Every hiring requirement narrows the available talent pool. Industry experience. Prior private equity exposure. Big Four training. Specific ERP expertise. Geographic location. Onsite expectations.
Individually, each requirement may be reasonable. Collectively, they can make an already challenging search significantly more difficult. Location is one of the clearest examples.
We work with companies that strongly prefer their finance leaders onsite, and there are legitimate business reasons for that preference. Controllers often work closely with operational leadership, and being physically present can be valuable, particularly during periods of transformation or rapid growth.
But requiring a candidate to work onsite five days a week in a market with a limited concentration of experienced finance professionals can substantially reduce the number of qualified candidates available.
That doesn’t mean companies should abandon their preferences or compromise on what matters to their business, but it’s important to understand the implications of those decisions. If a company requires highly specialized experience and has limited geographic flexibility, it may need to adjust compensation expectations or allow more time to complete the search.
Alternatively, expanding the geographic reach, considering hybrid arrangements or identifying transferable industry experience may open the door to candidates who would otherwise be overlooked. We’ve seen searches gain significant momentum when clients reassess just one requirement that was initially considered nonnegotiable.
Successful hiring isn’t about eliminating standards, but rather knowing which standards directly contribute to success in the role and where flexibility creates opportunity.
What our most successful searches have in common
The controller market is competitive, and I don’t expect that to change anytime soon.
Experienced accounting leaders are in demand, the expectations placed on them continue to grow and companies are competing for professionals who can contribute well beyond traditional financial reporting.
But a competitive market doesn’t have to mean a prolonged search.
The controller searches we’ve seen close successfully and within our clients’ preferred timelines have several things in common: leadership teams are aligned on the business need, compensation is informed by current market conditions and hiring requirements are evaluated with a clear understanding of their impact on the available talent pool. Just as importantly, those companies are prepared to move when they identify the right candidate.
A well-defined search strategy creates the opportunity to identify strong talent. A decisive hiring process is what allows companies to secure it. The companies that get this right aren’t simply better at recruiting. They’re better prepared to hire. And in today’s controller market, that distinction can be the difference in winning your preferred candidate in 45 days or less.
SIMILAR ARTICLES
Meaningful conversations: How our deal-sourcing team connects with founders
We launched our transaction services business with the guiding philosophy that meaningful conversations lead to successful deals.
The new era of workplace wellness at Charles Aris
Throughout the past year, we’ve also integrated firmwide activities into our culture to promote healthy meditation, social events and exercise.
Charles Aris in the community
Our firm places a high value on giving back to our communities, and our team members have been working alongside several organizations to do so.
